Keyboard shortcuts

Press ← or → to navigate between chapters

Press S or / to search in the book

Press ? to show this help

Press Esc to hide this help

Phase 05 — Expand real-data coverage behind the weak analyses

Goal

Each biology analysis that the manuscript currently hedges as coverage-limited is strengthened by real data where feasible: MANC produces finite graph metrics (or the data-quality cause is pinned down), morphometric scaling gains ≥1 independent dataset, the dual-network set gains ≥1 dataset, and developmental gains a dataset if one is available — then the numerals are regenerated through the analyses harness and the Limitations list is updated to reflect the new reality.

Why this matters now

Limitations currently admits: MANC v0.9 returned non-finite Gini/α; the morphometric exponent “rests almost entirely on NeuroMorpho” (Allen n=50, FlyWire n=16); the validated dual-network set is only C. elegans ×2 + Ciona; developmental rests on a single Witvliet dataset. With the main figures now carrying more weight (Tight-5), shoring up these analyses raises the evidentiary floor.

Sub-layer table

#SlugModel / EffortTouchesFile
01manc-rerunDeepSeek v4 Flash (opencode) / highgraph-precompute config for MANCsub-01-manc-rerun.md
02morphometry-ingestDeepSeek v4 Pro (opencode) / highETL: new morphometry datasetsub-02-morphometry-ingest.md
03dual-network-ingestDeepSeek v4 Pro (opencode) / highETL: new gap-junction datasetsub-03-dual-network-ingest.md
04developmental-coverageDeepSeek v4 Flash (opencode) / highETL/registry: developmental datasetsub-04-developmental-coverage.md

Disjoint by dataset/analysis. None edits bio/*.tex or discussion.tex — the numerals and Limitations edits are batched in the merge so the sub-layers don’t fight over the prose.

Merge plan

  1. Collect each sub-layer’s outcome: dataset ingested / MANC recomputed, or an explicit “not available — caveat stands” determination with evidence.
  2. Regenerate numerals — do not hand-edit: run python -m syndb_plot.manuscript.run_biological_analyses (production mode) once; re-reconcile the affected article/sections/bio/*.tex files from its output. Update the reproducibility anchor (new dated run dir).
  3. Update article/sections/discussion.tex Limitations: soften/remove the bullets the new data resolved; keep (with updated wording) those that remain. Coordinate landing order with Phase 02 (both touch discussion.tex: 02 → 05).
  4. Regenerate any affected figures (CF06/CF03/CF09/CF10) from the new analyses output via the figure pipeline.
  5. Build gate (lualatex ×2 + bibtex if new dataset citations added).

Acceptance criteria (phase-level)

  • At least one of: MANC yields finite Gini/α (or a pinned data-quality cause documented), morphometry gains an independent dataset, dual-network gains a dataset, developmental gains a dataset — each from real ingested data.
  • All changed biology numerals come from a fresh run_biological_analyses run; the reproducibility anchor dir is updated; no bio/*.tex numeral was hand-edited (diff traceable to the run output).
  • Limitations bullets updated to match the new coverage (resolved ones removed/softened).
  • Affected figures regenerated; lualatex ×2 + bibtex exit 0, 0 undefined refs.

Global constraints

Inherits the plan README rules. Never hand-edit numerals. New dataset citations go in references.bib. Preserve figure numbering.

Reference

  • Limitations list in article/sections/discussion.tex.
  • .claude/skills/manuscript/ (datasets table; analyses harness).
  • Memory: “Graph precompute in ETL”; “Manuscript analysis state”.
  • Gap inventory items 8–12.